Superleague

The latest news here!

 

Previous Page > A dangerous game
- for more stories, see below


Friday, June 25, 2010 : Nick Malkoutzis looks at the perils of mixing sport and politics
Harold WilsonIf you typed the word "Greece" into an Internet search engine a few weeks ago, all you would have got in return were stories about the economic crisis. If you conducted the same search over the past few days, those reports would have been about the national team's involvement in the World Cup. That's the power of sport - it doesn't always write history but it defines the present and that's the hard currency the world's politicians increasingly deal in, which is why they both love and fear sport, especially its most popular exponent, football.

Sport has a unique ability to unite disparate sections of society in a way that politicians can only dream of. No amount of slick campaigning or spin doctoring can give leaders the kind of universal appeal they get by associating themselves with successful sportsmen or teams. No amount of populist rhetoric and analysis of focus group statistics can help politicians connect with the public in the way that relating to sport can.

"You can occupy a cathedral and you will have upset Catholics, a fringe of approving dissidents, an indulgent left wing, while the secular parties will be (secretly) happy. You can occupy a party's headquarters, and other parties, with or without a show of solidarity, will think it serves them right," wrote Italian author and philosopher Umberto Eco. "But if a football stadium is occupied, the disclaiming of responsibility will be total: Church, Left, Right, State, Judiciary, Divorce League, anarchist unions, all will send the criminals to the pillory."

An example of how football can lure politicians who want to bask in its glory came at the beginning of this week when Prime Minister George Papandreou, who hitherto had not shown any interest in sport beyond jogging and going to the gym, lauded Greece for its 2-1 win over Nigeria at the World Cup and suggested it should serve as an example for his government. "The Greek national soccer team won because the players displayed team spirit, which is something that Greece needs if it is to overcome the economic crisis," he said.

Interestingly, the prime minister had not commented on Greece's 2-0 defeat to South Korea in the opening game, when the team's disjointed performance would presumably have served as an even timelier reminder that his government will have difficulty getting anything done if it remains as divided as it is now. Equally, the 2-0 loss against Argentina might suggest that a lack of decisiveness in the face of powerful forces will lead to the country's ultimate failure.

Politicians toy with sport at their peril - its outcome cannot be predicted by an opinion poll and it has an uncanny knack of refusing to conform. Papandreou joins a long line of his political colleagues that have hoped a positive result on the field of play would lead to favorable developments off it. Most of them end up being deeply disappointed.

In 1970, British Prime Minister Harold Wilson had been hoping that a rousing display by England at that summer's World Cup in Mexico would help his Labour Party be reelected. But England, then world champions, suffered a shock 3-2 defeat to West Germany in the quarter-finals despite having led their opponents 2-0 late in the game.

Four days later, on June 18, Wilson and Labour suffered an unexpected loss of their own at the ballot box despite having held a 7.5 percent lead in the opinion polls three weeks earlier. Wilson denied any connection between the two events.

"Governance of a country has nothing to do with a study of its football fixtures," he said. But the memoirs of top officials published in later years revealed that strategy meetings had been held when the elections were called to discuss the possible impact of an England defeat.

French President Nicolas Sarkozy is the latest leader to reap the ill-wind of a sporting disaster after his country's national team imploded in the most spectacular way at the World Cup. The decision of striker Nicolas Anelka to cast aspersions about the sexual habits of unpopular coach Raymond Domenech's mother during a half-time team talk sparked an almighty crisis of confidence within the team and crisis of conscience at home. Anelka was expelled by France's soccer federation after the content of his outburst was leaked to the press. The players refused to train the following day in protest at his dismissal.

Sarkozy dispatched his Sports Minister Roselyne Bachelot to try and smooth things over. Bachelot said that she and the president shared "the indignation of the French people" and called for "dignity and responsibility". Back in France, the squad's disintegration was seen as reflecting a failed society and a failing president. "Soccer should be exemplary, but instead it has become a symptom of everything that is wrong with France: the lack of respect pupils have towards their teachers, contempt for authority, civil disobedience," said Parisian Left Bank philosopher Alain Finkielkraut.

"We take them to be role models for kids who lost their way in life, but in reality they are just bling bling merchants for a sport which yesterday lost a lot of credit in France," wrote daily Liberation of the players. The newspaper's choice of words was probably no coincidence given that Sarkozy is also known as "President Bling Bling" for his showy, sometimes lavish, style.

"The shipwreck of the French team tells us something about the weaknesses of France, of a model of society that is based above all on money, which is adulated," said Francois Bayrou, president of the centrist Union for French Democracy. Socialist deputy Jerome Cahuzac went even further. "The atmosphere that prevails in the French team is one that Nicolas Sarkozy exults - it's all about individualism, egotism, everyone for themselves, and the only way to judge human success is the check you get at the end of the month," he said.

A public relations disaster of this magnitude is the last thing a president with declining ratings wants to deal with. Yet, this is exactly what Sarkozy has been forced to do. After an emergency meeting with Prime Minister Francois Fillon at the Elysee Palace on Wednesday, the president was due to meet star striker Thierry Henry on Thursday. The latter meeting was taking place at the request of the player, underlining just how sport has the power to master politics and not the other way around.

Sarkozy's travails are a far cry from the summer of 1998 when France won the World Cup on home soil with a squad known as the "Blacks, Blancs, Beurs" (Blacks, Whites, Arabs) that was the epitome of racial harmony and social cohesion. Then, President Jacques Chirac and Prime Minister Lionel Jospin enjoyed a double digit surge in their poll ratings. It helps explain why for decades, politicians have tried to harness sport's positive power and deflect its negative energy. But ultimately, sport, particularly football, has proved too raw, too elusive and too ephemeral for politics to capture and tame. The politicians that remain in the hunt are clearly playing a dangerous game.


This article viewed 623 times.
Created on Friday, June 25, 2010  03:57
Last updated on Friday, June 25, 2010  06:17

Print Article     ::     
Chelsea put a block on Greek fans
Non-members barred from Olympiakos game
King of the Tip: round 23
SIG writers Barney Spender and Graham Wood look ahead to round 23 of the Super League
Greece squad 2009-10
Caps and stats for current Greece squad
Sporting legacy for Broadway actor
Barney Spender looks back at how late Greek actor George Costacos became linked with George Best
Addicted to the quick fix
Nick Malkoutzis asks whether Greece can learn from Jamaica after its doping fiasco
Vardinoyiannis' hold of Panathinaikos disputed
High-profile fans, former players issue statement
Cisse signs four-year deal at PAO
Striker becomes Greece's most expensive player
Anorthosis 3 Panathinaikos 1
Greeks fall again to Cypriot curse
Ancient Games - ahead of the times
A look at the heros and mores of the Ancient Olympic Games
Cisse double sends PAO top
Greens join Olympiakos in first place
A novel approach to the game
Athens-based crime writer Paul Johnston talks rugby with sportingreece.com
Ergotelis teen star off to Arsenal
Karelis to join Gunners on trial
Super League results
Results and scorers from the 2008-9 Super League
Super League results
Results and scorers of 2009-2010 season
Super League results 2007-8
Results summary 2007-8
Vardinoyiannis to sell big stake in PAO
Share capital increase to fetch 80 million euros
Panathinaikos 1 Rangers 1
Novo breaks Panathinaikos hearts
AEK's Pliatsikas heading for Schalke
Tasos Kyriakos goes to Cyprus
Greece 2 Spain 3
Greeks beaten as Zagorakis bows out
Levadiakos 2007-8
First team squad
Panathinaikos 1 Larissa 2
Larissa stun the favourites to win Greek Cup
Champions League
Results Wednesday September 19
Kiprotich and Ponomarenko win ACM
Kenyans dominate the marathon again
Champions League results round 4
Results and scorers from Champions League
Thrasyvoulos lose, Panserraikos draw
Aghios Dimitrios change coaches again
Allez les Bleus!
French rugby tournament in Athens
European Champions since 1960
European champions since 1960
Great Games bad for Greece
Barney Spender picks over the bones of Beijing
Karagounis among world's top 100
IFFHS most popular player vote has begun
Panathinaikos hit back in Siena
Greens win 72-53 to close in on Final Four
Oruma signs for Kavala
Nigerian striker in Greece on one-year deal
Invictus
Barney Spender looks at the movie and compares it with the reality of 1995
Denilson comes and goes like a comet
Brazilian leaves Kavala, returns home
SIG's World Cup 2010 Blog
SIG writers share their daily thoughs
World Cup King of the Tip 1
SIG writers look ahead to the opening round of games in the World Cup
Rehhagel ponders Argentina hurdle
Coach revels in Greece's win over Nigeria
World Cup King of the Tip 11
Barney Spender and Graham Wood look forward to Monday's games at the World Cup
World Cup King of the Tip 12
George Georgakopoulos and Nick Malkoutzis on groups A and B
A dangerous game
Nick Malkoutzis looks at the perils of mixing sport and politics